Login

Your cart

4.9 · 13,000+ reviews

Your cart is empty

Find the ring you'll wear forever.

Continue shopping
New here? Get 10% off your first order.
Join our email list and we'll send your code.

Non Traditional Engagement Rings for Women

Unique engagement rings for women: sapphire, moss agate and opal instead of the diamond, sized for her hand and made for every day.

4.9 from 13,736
Free engraving
Easy exchanges
Free ring sizer
Family-run in Florida - making rings since 2017
All 131Moss AgateOpalGarnetMoonstoneSandstone
16 rings
Filters
Clear all filters
Ophelia vintage opal engagement ringSave $24.00OpalOphelia Vintage Fire Opal Ring $149 $125 Gold engagement ring with a green emerald opal.OpalGold Celtic Kite Opal Engagement Ring Set $149 Enla garnet and black fire opal women’s wedding ring black inlaySave $17.00Garnet Enla Garnet & Black Fire Opal Wedding Ring in Black $135 $118 Women's rose gold sterling silver bridal set with a round black fire opal, shown straight onOpal Veloura Black Fire Opal Ring Set $149 Women's sterling silver cluster ring with white opals and pink morganite, angled front viewOpalCluster Constellation Ring $135 White lotus engagement ring oval cut white sapphire rose goldSapphireWhite Lotus Engagement Ring $149 Women's vintage black fire opal bridal set in black sterling silver with white pear side stonesSave $22.00Opal Vintage Black Fire Opal Ring Set $149 $127 Women's black sterling silver shield-cut black fire opal engagement ring with a curved band, close cropOpal Lumiere Black Fire Opal Ring $149 Women's vintage white fire opal bridal set in sterling silver, oval opal ring with a crown-style bandOpal Vintage White Fire Opal Engagement Ring $149 Women's vintage-style rose gold sterling silver pear white fire opal bridal set, straight onSave $19.00OpalVintage Opal Engagement Ring $149 $130 Women's sterling silver pear-cut white fire opal bridal set with crown band and accent stones, close front viewOpal White Fire Opal Engagement Ring $149 Women's gold sterling silver white fire opal bridal set with crown band, close front viewOpal Vintage Gold Opal Engagement Ring $149 Women's vintage-style sterling silver oval black fire opal engagement ring set, close front viewSave $17.00Opal Vintage Black Fire Opal Ring $149 $132 White opal bridal set in sterling silver with pink morganite side stones and a curved band, front viewSave $27.00Opal Lumiere Morganite Opal Ring $149 $122 Women's sterling silver bridal set with a marquise opalescent sapphire and moonstone accents, close-up straight onSave $22.00SapphireOpalescent Moonstone Engagement Ring $149 $127 Sterling silver bridal set with a black fire opal center and garnet accents, shown straight onOpalLumiere Black Fire Opal Ring $149

More engagement rings

All engagement ringsFor menMatching sets for couplesMoss agate rings
Non traditional engagement ring for women with a unique center stone

Choosing a unique engagement ring for her

Setting
Simple solitaire-style rings keep a single stone front and center. Clusters and accent-framed settings add sparkle around it, and nature inspired details like vines and leaves turn the band into part of the design.
Stone shape
Kite and coffin cuts are the signature of a non traditional engagement ring; ovals and rounds keep an alternative stone feeling classic. Pick the silhouette first, then the color: the same cut comes in sapphire, moss agate, opal and sandstone.
Her style
Match the ring to the jewelry she already wears. Dainty engagement rings fit a light, stacked look, and a vintage-leaning solitaire never dates. If she is drawn to the outdoors, moss agate and vine details will feel like hers; if her style runs dark, black stones and gothic lines will.

An engagement ring does not need a diamond to carry the moment. Engraving inside the band is free, resizing exchanges are free if the fit misses, and every order ships with a ring sizer.

Questions before you buy

What hand does an engagement ring go on?

The left ring finger in the US, though plenty of brides break that rule on purpose. Our engagement ring hand guide covers the traditions and the exceptions.

What size should I order if the proposal is a surprise?

Most women wear between a size 5 and 7, with 6 the most common. If you can borrow a ring she wears on that finger, measure it with our at-home sizing guide. If you cannot, order your best guess; resizing exchanges are free and every order ships with a ring sizer.

Can she wear it every day?

Yes. These rings are made for daily wear, not for the safe. Stones sit in protective settings, sterling silver polishes back to new, and the lifetime warranty backs the ring for all the years after the yes.

Can the ring be engraved?

Yes, free: a date, initials or a short phrase inside the band, where only she knows it is there.

What if she says yes but the ring does not fit?

Resizing exchanges are free. Order the closest size, and if it misses, send it back and the right size ships out.

4.9 ★★★★★ 13,736 verified reviews
“She loves her rings and she said yes.”★★★★★ Jon B., verified buyer
“The ring is beautifully crafted. I am very pleased with my order.”★★★★★ Elizabeth R., verified buyer
“Absolutely stunning.”★★★★★ Sarah W., verified buyer
“This ring is absolutely gorgeous, the picture does not do it justice.”★★★★★ Melinda, verified buyer

Every order includes

  • EngravingInside the band, any date, initials or short phrase
  • Ring sizerShips with every order; check your size at home
  • ResizingIf the fit misses, we adjust it at no cost
  • Lifetime warrantyMade to last, guaranteed for life